Ratings & Reviews

Overall Rating

(31 reviews)
71% of customers recommend this property

Rating Per Category


Your Review

Submit a Review

Resident Reviews

submitted by Jonah B. - |Recommended: YesGreat apartment — I had some issues moving in, but the staff here are wonderful and very helpful. They all have gone out of their way to make things right and get my apartment, lease everything in order. I have just come back to the USA and found rented the apartment from Kuwait The staff here made everything as smooth as can be expected. My apartment is right near the parking garage and MARTA tracks, so it is a bit loud but the interior is beautiful, with a modern kitchen and bathroom. I have a one-bedroom model and it is very large, spacious and includes a nice little patio overlooking the pool. The outdoor area's could be cleaner, but to be fair I've moved in during a time of minimal staffing and COVID 19 restrictions. Most important to me in choosing Pencil Factory Flats was the location, I work at Grady Health and can walk there in 10-12 minutes. As well, Pencil Factory Flats honored a First Responder move in special - Any company that helps us out, especially now during uncertain times and an incredible amount of workI patients, I believe should get a big shout out.
response from property -Thank you so much for the rating and review. We were upset with ourselves that your move in did not go smoothly on the first day, but are very pleased to hear about your stay so far. And really, its you all, the First Responder's, Doctors, Nurses, NA, and anyone having to deal with the COVID19 Pandemic should get a big shout out!! We will be back to full staff on Monday, so if you haven't noticed yet today, things are cleaning up nicely. And thank you for understanding being half staff every other day. It really make a big difference, but we are moving forward and Pencil Factory will look like a brand new #2 Pencil when we are done! Than you again for everything
submitted by Griffin B. - |Recommended: YesEnjoyed living here — Its very urban. Gives you a good feel of atlanta.
response from property -Thank you for the review. We are happy that you are enjoying calling Pencil Factory Home!! If there is anything we can do, let us know.
submitted by Tumeka B. - |Recommended: YesI LOVE THE LICATION — I LOVE IT
response from property -Thank you for the rating and review. I know its been a rough time being stuck in the home, but we do have something planned for all of our Neighbors early next month!! We hope to see you there, its going to be an event ABOVE the rest!!
submitted by Ogheneruno U. - |Recommended: YesThe property is great — Leasing office professionals are very helpful, maintenance is helpful and timely. Upkeep of the apartments is very good.
response from property -Thank you very much for the rating and very nice review. We really appreciate all our neighbors and like to keep the community clean as possible for everyone to enjoy. Let us know if there is anything you need. Thank you again, Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager Pencil Factory
submitted by Jenna H. - |Recommended: NoNot worth it. — When I moved in I had a severe flea infestation that finally got cleared up after over a month, and when I called the leasing office they said it would be a week before pest control could come out. We then had a mouse infestation for 6 months and for the reminder of my lease we have had a roach infestation. Neighbors are so messy and dirty and that's why we have all the vermin. After a few months of living here, they randomly increased our rent quite a bit for “having a washing machine”, which we did not sign for an increased lease after a few months. Have had to call the cops several times on the venue below for blasting music at 4 am. Maintenance men are INCREDIBLY NICE. Zach at the leasing office was always very accommodating.
response from property -Hello Jenna, Thank you for taking the time to rate and review Pencil Factory. I would like to address the issue of your rent being raised without notice or signing anything. I do have a copy of your signed Washer/Dryer addendum stating the amount you would be paying per month for the Washer and Dryer, so I am a bit confused as to it was a "random increase in your rent quite a bit?" Again, if you would like I can email it to you and your roommates showing where you all signed the addendum as well as my assistant, Nicole signed it as well. Then on the issues with your mouse infestation, was it a mouse you had, or did you and infestation of mice? Now with the Venue below, I was not aware your apartment was over any of the retail shops? May I ask what venue is below you so I can let their management company know about it, as we do not manage the retail stores, just the resident buildings. And yes, pest control does come out every Friday, so if you ever need them again, just call, or email us here in the office and we can put you on their list for that Friday. Please feel free let us know if there is anything else we can do or answer for you. We are here for you and all our Neighbors. Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager
submitted by Daemon L. - |Recommended: NoGreat and beautiful apartment but... — I love my apartment and the property. It’s very close to everything and I enjoy walking around downtown Atlanta. There are a few things I find not good, such as extremely noisy upstairs neighbors that I have messaged the office about multiple times and nothing has changed. The dog area is ALWAYS covered in poop no owner accountability and the people who “clean” it don’t do a very good job . The security on the doors are great when they work. A lot of the doors are either bent and damaged in some way or for a very long time, some of the doors just flat out didn’t magnetically lock. The gate is great but really needs an update to make it safer, especially for the area. The security officers are fantastic and do their job very well, which makes the property feel safe at night. I want to recommend this place to friends because of the beautiful apartments, but with all the downsides especially the excessively noisy upstairs neighbors that constantly keep us up at night , there needs to be a major work up on the property before I could be able to do that.
response from property -Dear Daemon, I am sorry about your upstairs neighbors, as this is the first I am hearing about it. I will send an email to that apartment to ask them to keep it down. Also, can you be more specific on which doors are not locking or not working? We do try to have them repaired as quickly as possible. The one on floor 2 from the garage is working correctly now as it was out of alignment when they last came out. I would love to hear about these other issues you have as well, so if you could just email me at pencilfactorymgr@lincolnapts.com, I would be happy to get them taken care of for you. Thank you for taking the time to fill out the rating and review, Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager 404-525-7000
submitted by Tasneem A. - |Recommended: YesCould use more work for the price — The location is awesome The convenience store down stairs is a major plus. Parking is very reasonable. Downfalls are the walls being way too thin. You can hear any and everything. The up-keeping of the property could be worked on a little more, especially for the price For example, random furniture trash sitting in the hallway for days and garbage piled up outside of the dumpster.
response from property -Thank you for the rating and review. I know there have been times when the trash has backed up at the compactor, but that was either because some of the retail stores didnt know how to work it, or it was actually broken. Then we had to get it repaired. We time it was broken, we would order an open top container, but the compactor would be fixed before the open top would make it. We will try to keep a sharper eye out in the breezeways for large items Valet Living will not take as well. Let us know if there is anything else we can do for you Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager
submitted by Robert S. - |Recommended: YesMoving was a big change for me — I have to say that moving to a big city was a very hard decision for me, but Pencil Factory has so much of what anyone needs, I barely leave the block Everyone just about knows everyone, and everyone is so friendly. I love it here
response from property -Thank you for your rating and review, and we are very glad you found a place you can call home in a new city.
submitted by Mikayla H. - |Recommended: YesCute downtown apartment — This apartment is right in downtown Atlanta being a conveniently close to Georgia state university. It is a bit noisy but for the price and the area you won’t find a better place.
response from property -Thank you for taking the time to rate and review Pencil Factory. If there is anything we can do to make your stay with us more enjoyable, please let us know. Thank you again for taking the time out of your day for this rating and review. We do appreciate honest reviews such as this one. Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager
submitted by Joe H. - |Recommended: YesVery nice — It is a good place to stay.
response from property -Thank you for taking the time to rate and review us here at Pencil Factory! We are pleased to hear that you call it a good place to stay. If there is anything you need, just let us know!! Again, thank you for taking time out of your day to leave us a rating and review Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager Pencil Factory
submitted by Tyler D. - |Recommended: Yes. — .
response from property -Thank you for the four star rating. We do appreciate it very much. If there is anything we can do, please let us know.
submitted by Kristen V. - |Recommended: NoUnfortunate Experiences Overshadow — Bobby and Amy are great. Unfortunately, the experience I have had living at the pencil factory has been disappointing and unbelievably below living standards. As a young professional returning to school, I was so excited to find this location. It has been nothing short of unbearable. I will not recommend this location to anyone until certain living standards are met.
response from property -Thank you for your honest rating and review of Pencil Factory. I know we have spoke several times about things, and I really wish there was something more that I could do to make your stay with us more pleasurable and a place you would love to call home. I will continue on our end in the office doing what we can to hopefully remedy at least one of the main concerns you have very soon. Thank you again for the open, honest rating and review, as it gives us something to work on and possibly earn a changed review in the future. Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager Pencil Factory
submitted by Latishia C. - |Recommended: NoReview — Wouldn't live here again, paying for the connivence of being downtown but management has poor communication skills. Maintenance does not respond quickly. not an overall good experience.
response from property -I'm sorry to hear you feel that way about Pencil Factory and Management. I'm surprised about the poor communication skills comment, as we send out emails updated everyone on what is going on, events we are having, and same with all of our Social Media. I would like to know more about what we can do to better our communication kills to our Neighbors. Yes, maintenance was slow in the beginning, as we only had one maintenance technician that was allowed in occupied apartment homes, but we have a full team now and request have been being handled within same day or 24 hours. If there is something we have overlooked in your apartment, please let me know and I will address it directly with our maintenance team and make sure its taken care of Monday. Give me a call at 404-525-7000 or email us a pencilfactory@lincolnapts.com Thank you for taking the time to leave the rating and review, as we do take these serious. Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager
submitted by Logan L. - |Recommended: YesGood area and property, but some maintenance problems — Its a great area, and a great building as a whole. However, there is always something wrong in our apartment. From our dishwasher breaking, to stove breaking, to shower not draining, door and door handles coming off, and AC breaking, it has been a rough move-in. But the staff are extremely helpful and always friendly.
response from property -I am sorry to hear about your hard time moving in. I know the frustration it caused, and thank you for being patient with us while we worked with you on getting things back together for you. We do truly want everyone to enjoy calling Pencil Factory Home! If there is anything you need please let us know and Ill make sure it get's taken care of. Bobby Starnes, CAM Business Manager
submitted by Kakenya W. - |Recommended: YesConvenient location... — The property is centrally located which makes it convenient to all things Atlanta...the amenities leave much to be desired. The dog park is horrid literally like tip toeing through a sh tty land-fill. The hallways need to be pressured washed they reek trash. The bugs roaches are all bad as well, especially after trash is pulled. The staff is pleasant and seemly want to do the right thing but inherited a ton of issues.
response from property -Thank you for the rating and review. We do have plans for the breezeways coming up this year, but I think pressure washing your floor would push water under the doors in the breezeway. With that being said, I will get with our Maintenance Supervisor and see if there is someone we can do that will be just as effective, yet less invasive. Also, I will have pest control treat that breezeway tomorrow while he is here. That should be a good start to any pest issues. And the Bark Park, I know maintenance has been cleaning it up, but I just need to send out a notices letting others know to pick up after their pets, since we do have a waste station right beside the entrance. Thank you for the opportunity to address these issues and concerns.

The views and opinions expressed herein are solely those of the original authors and other contributors. These views do not reflect the views of "Pencil Factory Flats", its owners, managers, agents, employees or content providers. No representation or warranty, express or implied, is made or given by "Pencil Factory Flats", its owners, managers, agents, employees or content providers regarding safety, accuracy, completeness or suitability of the information or material expressed herein for any particular purpose